This analysis delves into the functionality and practicality of the Made In Grill, a charcoal cooking device, examining its ability to deliver intense heat and consistent performance. This report offers insights into its design, including a flexible charcoal basket and durable grate, as well as its adaptability for various cooking tasks, such as searing meats and vegetables or using it as a griddle. While acknowledging its effectiveness in heating and cooking, it also addresses challenges related to its weight and the maneuverability of certain components.

The Made In Grill, launched last year, quickly gained attention for its innovative design, resembling an all-metal Konro grill. Its key features include a movable charcoal basket for heat control and wide metal strips on the grate to prevent food from falling. Despite selling out rapidly upon its initial release, a subsequent version was tested to evaluate its performance and determine if its premium price is justified. The testing process involved setting up the grill, igniting charcoal, and cooking various items such as bratwurst, corn, smash burgers, zucchini, and salmon, noting the ease of setup, cooking efficiency, and post-cooking cleanup. This thorough examination aimed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the grill's capabilities in real-world scenarios.

One of the primary findings from the evaluation was the grill's exceptional ability to generate and maintain high heat. Whether igniting charcoal directly within the basket or transferring pre-heated coals from a chimney starter, the grill achieved white-hot temperatures within a short period, typically around 25 minutes. The robust stainless steel grate quickly absorbed and distributed heat, resulting in deep caramelization and distinct sear marks on all tested foods. This design, featuring broad slats rather than thin bars, ensured efficient heat transfer and minimized the risk of smaller food items slipping into the flames. Additionally, the carbon steel griddle, used for preparing smash burgers, demonstrated impressive heat retention, contributing to uniformly browned patties with crispy edges. These consistent results, even beyond the initial testing phase, indicated that the Made In Grill consistently reaches and sustains high temperatures, surpassing the performance of smaller alternatives.

A notable feature of the Made In Grill is its movable charcoal basket, which provides excellent control over heat intensity. Unlike traditional charcoal grills that require manual rearrangement of coals, this grill allows users to adjust the basket's height. Raising the basket brings the coals closer to the cooking surface, intensifying the heat for rapid searing, while lowering it facilitates slower, more gradual cooking. The updated two-slot design offers improved stability compared to its predecessor, with two distinct height options proving sufficient for most grilling applications. This adjustability enhances cooking precision, allowing for versatile culinary techniques.

However, the grill's portability remains a significant consideration. Weighing 30 pounds, it is considerably heavier than many portable alternatives. While the manufacturer made efforts to reduce its weight from the previous 35-pound model, it still poses a challenge for easy transportation to locations requiring extended walks, such as beaches or remote picnic spots. This weight, primarily due to its solid carbon steel construction, suggests that the Made In Grill is better suited for patio or backyard use rather than highly mobile grilling adventures.

While the movable charcoal basket and removable grill grate offer functional advantages, their design presents some operational challenges. Adjusting the charcoal basket's height can be cumbersome, with instances where it snags on one side or scrapes against the tucked-away grill grate. The removable grill grate, although a beneficial improvement over the previous non-removable version, can be precarious. During testing, a moment of concern arose when the grate inadvertently slid into the rear slot after charcoal had been added, making it difficult to reposition without high-temperature gloves. It is advisable to remove the grate entirely before adding hot charcoal to ensure safety and ease of use.

The Made In Grill is designed for rapid heating and sustained high temperatures, thanks to its carbon steel construction. Its adaptable charcoal basket allows for precise heat management, accommodating both quick searing and slow cooking. The grill grate is also removable, simplifying cleaning and enabling its transformation into a griddle with an optional carbon steel accessory. However, its substantial price and heavy build, alongside the sometimes awkward movement of internal components, are important factors to consider. Despite these minor inconveniences, its overall performance makes it a strong contender for serious outdoor cooking enthusiasts.